2024 Rookie Draft

51–76 minutes

Unlike last year, I won’t be assigning letter grades to each pick. Instead, I’ll provide a scouting report for each player in the draft class, organized by team. I’ll rank each team’s draft class, starting with the worst and ending with the best.

This year’s draft was marked by significant movement, a refreshing change from the previous year. Many teams chose to accumulate draft capital, aiming to hit the jackpot with their selections. However, I won’t automatically favor teams with more picks over those with fewer. The rankings will be based on the overall quality of each team’s draft decisions, acknowledging that a single exceptional pick can greatly influence the assessment of an entire class.

When going through each player, I’ve compiled scouting reports and assessments from a couple of my favorite film guys. There’s an overview of what was said prior to the draft and a quick excerpt post draft, typically explaining immediate impact on their real life team. Hopefully these assessments will help give each of you a better understanding of not only your own draft class, but with each rookie that was picked.

Justin Fields Forever

Xavier Legette
Pre-Draft:
Legette is often compared to D.K. Metcalf due to his size and speed, though he lacks Metcalf’s hip mobility and physicality at the catch point. However, Legette is lighter and shorter than Metcalf. With that, it positions Legette on a spectrum of similar athletes, noting he has potential but isn’t yet a primary receiver. He resembles Alshon Jeffery in terms of being a valuable WR2 with big-play potential due to his physicality and athleticism but lacks deep-route prowess.
Legette’s strengths include using his size and speed effectively at the catch point, strong hands, and good release footwork. He needs to improve patience in his routes, hand violence against tight coverage, and striking in the run game. While he understands basic receiver techniques, he must refine his skills for the NFL and learn zone coverages.
Legette’s potential is highlighted by his ability to drop weight and force pursuit to overrun angles, drawing comparisons to David Boston and A.J. Brown. He’s considered a borderline starter, with potential to thrive in a team with strong veteran receivers who can guide him. Initially, he may struggle with nuances of coverage and separating from top corners but could develop into a competent secondary option capable of big plays.
Ceiling?
A poor man’s David Boston or A.J. Brown who can impose his will as a runner on RPOs, screens, and slants as well as win on digs, fades, posts and sail routes where his size is an asset.
Floor?
Legette never progresses with his route running and can’t become a No.2 receiver in an offense. He’ll wind up a contributor with a specific set of routes for the gameplan but not enough targets to become a reliable producer.
Post-Draft:
If Bryce Young played to expectation, Legette would probably be seen as a first-round pick and be vastly overrated. Right now, he’s only slightly overrated. Legette, similar to Johnathan Mingo, lacks the technical acumen for beating man to man coverage at this point in their career.

The Final Boss

Brian Thomas Jr.
Pre-Draft:
Thomas is a big-play threat with the potential to become a primary option. He’s an explosive player who catches the ball well. There are only minor errors with attack and isolated in nature. The strength of Thomas’ game is currently as a vertical threat. He’s quick and physical enough to defeat press coverage and has developed enough release combinations to succeed early in his career as a downfield option. He’s a capable route runner in the short and intermediate ranges of the field, but he has room to grow into a primary threat once he refines his breaks to the extent that he can generate separation against tight coverage on timing routes breaking back to the quarterback.
Like A.J. Green, Thomas has wiry strength to shrug off pursuit in the open field and finish strong while also having the quick and precise feet to make opponents miss. He’s skilled enough to be a productive split end as a rookie if paired opposite with a primary option at flanker or and/or a big-play complement from the slot. He’ll make contested catches at the boundary and work free from tight coverage to run under targets from an accurate vertical passer.
Could Thomas become the next A.J. Green? Thomas hasn’t demonstrated Green’s physicality and creativity at the catch point nor has he shown Green’s elite route running precision. Still, there’s enough skill in his game that with additional refinement, he could earn comparisons that only feel like an insult to older Cincinnati and Georgia fans.
Ceiling?
A.J. Green-Lite
Floor?
Thomas fails to refine his routes and his role is more like D.J. Chark or Chris Henry—talented vertical threats who scare defenses but may not be as consistent as once advertised. I doubt Thomas’ floor reach those depths.
Post-Draft
Thomas may be forced into the split end role early where flanker might be more ideal early on. Either way, he has the skills to grow into the role. Thomas has the ceiling to deliver Mike Williams plus value to Trevor Lawrence in the way Williams delivered at Clemson.

Spencer Rattler
Pre-Draft
Rattler’s baseline is similar to Baker Mayfield but his strengths and weaknesses against coverage are the opposite. Mayfield entered the league having more difficulty with tight man-to-man coverage, especially with pressure forcing him to climb the pocket and make leverage reads and throws. Rattler has difficulty reading the position of defenders in zone coverage when his offense hasn’t schemed a play with only one place to throw the ball.
Rattler is much better at identifying open options based on defender position when he’s facing man-to-man coverage. Rattler’s greatest success against zone coverage occurs when his team leverages his mobility and accuracy with clear and quick reads as a distributor/point guard:

  • RPOs.
  • The quick game.
  • Play-action.
  • Designed rolls setting up quick-hitting plays.
  • Designed look-offs and embedded misdirection as window dressing to disguise the intent to target one receiver all along.

Otherwise, Rattler has difficulty reading the position of defenders in zone coverage when reading the field without schemed plays like the ones above.
When Rattler knows where to go with the ball, he has promising accuracy that should only improve if his understanding of coverage improves. His quick distribution of the football and ability to vary his releases and still deliver an accurate target is an impressive part of his game.
Rattler’s pocket management has improved, but he’s still not at a place where it’s a strength of his game. For him to develop into a good starter, he must move more efficiently. Like Mayfield early in his career, Rattler is not as comfortable climbing the pocket as he must become.
Don’t expect Rattler to become a long-term starter in the NFL, but he has enough promise to develop into a competent journeyman or reserve who, eventually, won’t completely implode if called upon.
Ceiling?
Rattler becomes a better reader of zone coverage and develops into a journeyman starter who could serve as a productive bridge between a recently deposed franchise stalwart or washed-out prospect and an early-round pick with franchise-starter promise.
Floor?
Rattler never becomes a fully-dimensional field general and is playing in a different league.
Post-Draft
Rattler is the attempt to develop a physically better version of Jake Haener but that’s hard to achieve. Rattler may hit, but you’ll probably have 2-3 years to see much value.

Northside Boys

J.J. McCarthy

Pre-Draft

“In January, a quarterback coach asked if McCarthy was Zach Wilson 2.0, implying he might be an overhyped player lacking NFL starter skills. Initially, I agreed but suggested McCarthy was a more advanced version of what the media expected Wilson to be.” Now, with the analysis complete, McCarthy still appears better positioned than Wilson, who was closer to a reserve player. McCarthy could contribute this year and potentially develop into a franchise starter, given a good landing spot.

Key differences between McCarthy and Wilson include McCarthy’s superior pocket management, technical grasp, athleticism, and occasional excellence in reading coverage. McCarthy, like Manziel, Lock, and Wilson, can be a reckless creator due to past success with off-script plays. While McCarthy shows promise in coverage reading and situational game management, he has recurring lapses, especially in the red zone.

Wilson’s good moments were exceptions, whereas McCarthy’s good-to-bad ratio favors the good but isn’t consistent enough yet. McCarthy’s strengths suggest he could excel in a West Coast or spread offense. His fundamentals indicate a lower risk of development issues compared to Manziel, Lock, and Wilson. However, if rushed into duty, there’s a moderate risk his game could deteriorate.
Unlike Manziel, Lock, and Wilson, who lacked detailed preparation and failed to build a strong foundation, McCarthy has the details needed to become a capable starter. The main question is whether he will develop the confidence to make quick, decisive throws. This anticipation is crucial for transitioning from a competent quarterback like Alex Smith to an elite one like Patrick Mahomes.
Ceiling?
What we’ve seen from Tua Tagovailoa at his best but with more arm strength. Maybe that’s Pro-Bowl caliber Jake Plummer.
Floor?
If he cannot improve his lapses as a game manager, reader of coverage, and improve his accuracy, McCarthy will tease, at best.
Post-Draft
McCarthy and Darnold share similar flaws coming out of school. Both missed defender drops, played too much hero ball in redzone and black-zone scenarios, and bailed the pocket when not necessary. McCarthy is better in the pocket than Darnold was. Like Darnold he showed upside with big-time throws but he’s less known of a commodity in the vertical passing game as Darnold.

Ja’Lynn Polk
Pre-Draft
Polk, along with teammate Jalen McMillan, sits in the RSP’s third tier of receiver prospects. He shows flashes of top-starter quality but lacks consistency and certain skills to be an immediate every-down option. Polk has the speed for a slant-flanker hybrid role but lacks a diverse release repertoire, limiting his immediate starting potential.
While Polk can occasionally beat defenders with his speed and manipulation of stems, he lacks the consistent nuance and detail needed against tight man-to-man coverage. He excels at using his hands to separate without pushing off, making him effective in the back-shoulder game. However, he needs more confidence to attack defenders at full speed and maximize separation on breaks.
Polk is a strong pass-catcher, capable of high-pointing and securing the ball away from defenders. He tracks the ball well and shows late hands on back-shoulder catches. His range and ability to extend for errant throws are impressive, though he needs to improve at attacking the ball at its earliest point.
In the NFL, Polk can make an immediate impact as an inside receiver against zone coverage, provided he masters the assignments and route adjustments. He’s effective at avoiding contact and setting up defenders after the catch, showing good decision-making to get downhill and exit the boundary when needed.
Polk has the potential to be a playmaker from the slot and might develop into a flanker. The main question is whether he can grow beyond being a rotational contributor to become a consistent, impactful player.
Ceiling?
A middle-class CeeDee Lamb who excels at smaller range of skills from the slot and limited snaps at flanker.
Floor?
A plus-version of Marquez Callaway who can offer a little more as a rout runner.
Post-Draft
If Polk landed with an established quarterback, I’d be more optimistic. On the basis of talent, Javon Baker may be the more versatile player. Polk has talent but might be a little overrated when compared to draft capital.

Ja’Tavion Sanders
Pre-Draft
Sanders has significant potential as a match-up receiver, utilizing his size, quickness, and technique to create mismatches when pressed at the line. While he possesses promising route and pass-catching skills, they need refinement. Like David Njoku and Jonnu Smith, Sanders’ athleticism will secure him early playing time, but his technical deficiencies might delay his full potential.
Sanders has a promising array of hand counters against press coverage and needs to develop a strong footwork toolbox to complement these counters. His acceleration and speed enable him to beat linebackers and safeties up the seam, making him an early read in intermediate and vertical routes. If Sanders refines his breaks in the intermediate game, he could become a primary option, creating matchup problems for defenses.
Downfield, Sanders excels at adjusting his frame to optimize run-after-catch opportunities. However, he needs to improve his target attacks, as his tendency to clap-attack increases drop risks. His large hands (10-1/8 inches) might mitigate some concerns, but like Njoku, he may need a wake-up call to refine his catching technique.
If Sanders can reduce unforced errors at the catch-point, his film already shows a strong catch radius, contested catches, and toughness. Once in possession, Sanders has the footwork, lateral movement, balance, and power to gain extra yardage, knowing when to bounce, cut back, or drop his pads for extra yards.
Sanders is a move tight end whose blocking is best for stalk blocks, lead blocks, and double-teams. He excels in lead-blocking assignments close to the line of scrimmage but needs to improve his hand placement for better striking.
In his rookie year, Sanders will likely have exciting moments in training camp and preseason but may only secure a contributing role unless injuries necessitate a starting position. If forced into an every-down role prematurely, he might struggle and make mistakes, potentially leading to undeserved public criticism.
Ceiling?
A top-five receiving tight end in the league.
Floor?
A role-player who earns only a low-volume of targets in an NFL passing game unless injuries decimate the primary options or coordinators devise gameplans for him against specific defenses that lead to the occasional big game.
Post-Draft
The play-action game will be important in Carolina and Sanders should figure prominently once he earns a role. Sanders has the ceiling to deliver as one of the top three receiving options on the field.

Rabbisproul

Will Shipley
Pre-Draft
Shipley is one of the top receiving backs in this class, with potential to become a lead back due to his receiving skills. Although his timed speed from Clemson’s Pro Day might be inflated, his acceleration and lateral movement make him effective against underneath coverage and on vertical routes. Shipley skillfully manipulates off-coverage and uses hand counters to maintain position, tracking the ball well and making athletic adjustments to win against tight coverage.

While his receiving game stands out, Shipley is also a quick processor at the line of scrimmage, excelling in setting up and splitting double teams as an inside runner. His technique and movement skills allow him to perform better between the tackles than some reports suggest. If he adds muscle and maintains his athleticism, he could have a better pro career than college career, especially in a high-powered offense. Otherwise, he may resemble a more explosive Bilal Powell or Kenneth Gainwell, effective in a lead role but with questioned long-term upside.
Ceiling?
Shipley becomes a lead back and top producer due to his versatility.
Floor?
Shipley becomes a complementary contributor or reserve with value in the return game and two-minute offense.
Post-Draft
Shipley is more likely to become what the Eagles hoped from Gainwell physically. Shipley’s route running could make him the passing-down back next year and give Barkley more breaks to save him.

Indianapolis Pale Ales

Malik Nabers
Pre-Draft
He’s an excellent route runner, starting with press coverage. An NFL primary receiver must win one-on-one matchups against top corners in critical game situations, even when the corner knows what’s coming. While beating press coverage is essential for a No.1 receiver, many prospects take 2-3 years to master it, if they ever do.
Most receiver prospects know some release techniques but lack the conceptual artistry to apply them effectively against pros. Some have 1-2 release combinations that work until cornerbacks catch on, but few have a wide range of combinations. Even fewer know which techniques to use based on the defender’s alignment, tells, intended route, and nearby coverage.
The best receivers possess a strong repertoire of techniques, the artistry to execute them effectively, and a broad understanding of football to choose the right moves for each situation. Nabers is among these select few. He uses pacing to set up sudden and violent techniques, efficiently transitioning into his stem or break.
Nabers excels in stems and breaks, understanding that efficiency is crucial for timing routes. His minor technique issues are isolated to a few reps, with multiple successful reps elsewhere. He plays with speed and control, a level of expertise some NFL veterans never achieve. Nabers combines this with acceleration, movement, and play-point toughness.
At the catch point, Nabers is tough, focused, and dynamic across the field. He’s a big-play option after the catch, capable of making defenders miss and setting up blocks. Despite skepticism about Odell Beckham’s size when he entered the NFL, his prime performances proved his capability. Similarly, Nabers will be an early pick and will remind fans of Beckham as a route runner and in his intensity during one-on-one scenarios, including blocking.
Ceiling?
A top-5 producer at his position.
Floor?
Amari Cooper-like: A quality primary option who has never been a top-5 producer but paces his offense and often delivers top-15 production.
Post-Draft
Nabers has the worst quarterback situation of the big-three rookie receivers, but it also means his team may have the best opportunity to remedy that problem in 2025 with a free agent or draft pick. Nabers is also the most capable of delivering starter production in a variety of roles even if his quarterbacks aren’t toptier producers right now.

Drake Maye
Pre-Draft
For at least the past year, Maye has been regarded as one of the top two quarterback prospects. He is the quintessential Robo-QB: a technically-sound athlete who checks the easy-to-define boxes such as playing for a prominent Division-I program, prolific yardage and scoring, requisite completion percentage, big frame, height, and a strong arm.
While these are positives, there are other crucial facets of quarterbacking that NFL decision-makers hope will develop with experience, including situational game management, pinpoint accuracy beyond completion percentage, processing coverage accurately, pre- and post-snap diagnosis, sensing pressure, and efficient pocket management. If a quarterback possesses some of these skills upon entering the league, it’s possible to refine them and fulfill their potential. However, about half of the Robo-QBs drafted in the first round fail to develop into franchise starters due to lacking these skills.
Maye fits the pre-draft billing based on the physical and statistical criteria but has work ahead regarding the more nuanced aspects of quarterbacking. His size, pocket toughness, big arm, and mobility are prominent on tape. However, like Baker Mayfield’s deceptive college completion percentage, Maye’s flaws in pocket management, reading coverage, and reluctance to take easy solutions will be more problematic in the NFL. Additionally, Maye’s accuracy, especially on-platform without pressure, isn’t as strong as his completion percentage suggests.
Entering the draft, Maye’s tape shows a quarterback who can contribute if needed but is closer to a reserve tier than a rotational starter. His vision, unnecessary pressure generation in the pocket, and technical lapses hinder his accuracy, making him ill-suited for a rebuilding organization. Bad teams rarely rebuild quickly enough to provide a quarterback with Maye’s issues the essential support to experience only the expected developmental bumps. Justin Fields is a prime example of a Robo-QB whose first team failed to provide consistent protection, veteran receivers, and a well-conceived scheme.
If Maye can refine his accuracy and game management, he could become a contributor that a team will build around to optimize his production potential. Improving his processing speed, confidence to act quickly, and pocket management could help Maye reach the franchise-starter potential expected of him. These are challenging issues to address, making Maye’s development the most uncertain among top prospects.
Ceiling?
A quality starter who could earn a second or third contract with his original team who plays low-error football and has elite production upside if paired with at least a top primary receiver and emerging or aging contributors of value in the receiving corps.
Floor?
Labeled career backup/journeyman before his first contract expires. If Maye’s accuracy issues and processing inconsistencies lead to a worst-case scenario, a comparison to Jake Locker as Maye’s floor-outcome will be fitting.
Post-Draft
Maye has the physical talent needed to star and he’s tough. Pocket management, accuracy, processing, and situational management are lacking too often. If the Patriots make good on their notion to bench Maye all year, there’s hope that he could develop to his ceiling. If they start him early, bets are off with this young receiving corps.

Trey Benson
Pre-Draft
Benson is a runner in the second tier who seems to be peaking at the right time, potentially becoming a productive NFL starter. He’s already big and fast enough and has become more decisive between the tackles. His skills with gap blocking and outside zone make him an appealing fit for NFL teams running Shanahan/McVay offenses, which prioritize speed and aggression over creativity and patience.
If Benson can improve his pre-snap reads and game management, he has the physical tools to become a lead back. He avoids risky decisions when deep in his own end or in the red zone, showing appropriate conservatism. Although he’s a powerful runner, he sometimes hesitates when facing unblocked linebackers, an issue that Rashaad White and Travis Etienne also had entering the league but have since improved.
Unlike White and Etienne, Benson needs to develop his route-running skills beyond screens, wide routes, and swing passes. He tracks the ball well but needs to refine his attack technique to reduce drops. His pass protection is also a work in progress, likely taking at least a year to become competent.
Given his potential, Benson could start as a rookie, but like White, he may not look as promising in his first year as he did in college. Ideally, he would benefit from a smaller role initially, using the offseason to address his deficiencies. If he improves quickly, gets a year to develop, and earns a role that minimizes his weaknesses, Benson could deliver immediate value. However, these are significant “ifs,” so while it’s possible, it’s not guaranteed.
Ceiling?
What those bullish about Marlon Mack at USF expected because he’s a more accomplished decision maker.
Floor?
A one-dimensional back who doesn’t improve his passing-down skills and winds up a talented reserve who can’t hang onto a starting gig because of these deficiencies.
Post-Draft
Benson is a good gap runner but still learning the nuances of some zone runs. Carter is a smart runner and underrated receiver. It’s possible Benson has smaller role as a rookie than those drafted after him. He’s a reasonable investment as the candidate to deliver like rookie RB2 in 2-3 years, but his landing spot is a bit oversold because the Cardinals a productive offense but not efficient.

Blake Corum

Pre-Draft
When factoring in injuries, skill, versatility, and athletic ability, Corum is arguably the safest running back in this class. This doesn’t necessarily mean he’s the best bet to become a starter of value, as his range of outcomes is quite wide for a second-ranked runner.
Corum is small enough that, if his processing and explosion don’t translate as well as projected, he could become a more functionally-sound and productive version of Mike Hart. For those who don’t remember Hart, the former Michigan starter was a third-string back for the Colts during his short stint in the NFL. While it’s possible Corum might begin his career as a third-string option, it’s unlikely that’s where he will end up, because even the low-end outcome of his explosion is probably as a second back in a rotation.
If Corum’s skills translate as expected and he can add another 5-10 pounds of muscle, he has the ability to at least earn a near 50/50 split in a backfield, if not take the lead role. He runs with excellent decision-making, is efficient with his movements, and is capable of quick-twitch dynamic footwork. Because he runs with strong pad level, contact aggression, and balance for his size, even a moderate addition of muscle could help him ascend a depth chart into a significant role.
If Corum’s skills translate as expected and he adds 10-15 pounds of muscle without sacrificing any of his explosion and mobility, he could have a similar outcome to Ray Rice. For those too young to remember Rice beyond his career-ending domestic violence incident, Rice entered the NFL as a 205-pound runner who carried the load at Rutgers. By his second year with the Ravens, Rice was 220 pounds and more explosive than he was as a rookie, becoming an elite NFL runner.
Corum has the vision between the tackles and in the open field, coupled with a toolbox of footwork and upper-body moves, to follow suit if he proves he can add the muscle to his frame that will help him become a lead back in the league. However, with a torn meniscus in 2022, there’s a concern whether Corum can add 15 pounds and remain productive long-term.
The area where Corum has the most to learn is pass protection. He’s an aggressive blocker who must dial back his attacks for more control in his interactions. Even so, he doesn’t have much to improve upon to become competent in this area.
In conclusion, Corum has one of the highest floors among the backs with talent that could develop further. However, he is also one of the smallest and slowest, which adds some uncertainty to his long-term potential.
Ceiling?
A career that has fans remembering Ray Rice’s peak work.
Floor?
A career as a second back in a rotation where he gets the small end of the workload.
Post-Draft
Corum lands in a good scheme with less proven talent to compete against. He’s the safest back in this class as a decision-maker. The nagging concern for Corum’s value is Sean McVay’s adherence to system to the point of stubbornness. If this happens with Corum, his opportunities could be delayed.

Adonai Mitchell
Pre-Draft
Mitchell transferred to Texas to be closer to his daughter and is an excellent vertical receiver who could become a productive secondary starter in the NFL, depending on his development in the short and intermediate route game. To become more well-rounded, Mitchell needs to improve the sharpness of his breaks and refine his release packages against man-to-man coverage.
Although Mitchell has violent hands and good footwork, he needs to better attack the leverage of his opponents. Speed is not an issue; he knows how to vary it and use leverage effectively during stems. With improved breaks inside, outside, and back to the quarterback, he can become a more complete receiver.
Currently, Mitchell can contribute in three- and four-receiver packages as a vertical option or on underneath routes but isn’t a primary matchup receiver due to technique lapses. As a pass-catcher, he rarely drops the ball but relies on an underhand trap technique that might be less effective in the NFL. He excels at tracking vertical passes and has a good feel for executing cutbacks after the catch.
Mitchell’s blocking can be overly aggressive, and he would benefit from focusing on sound positioning and control. While he has the least upside among the Tier II receivers in the rankings, he has a solid foundation to develop into a capable NFL starter soon.
Ceiling?
A receiver capable of 900-1,100 yards and 6-8 touchdowns in a high-powered offense.
Floor?
A third or fourth option who never rounds out his game to the extent that he can take pressure off the primary option without a second receiver who forces opponents to place their weakest link on Mitchell.
Post-Draft
Mitchell may be a better NFL starter than fantasy option, but if Michael Pittman gets hurt, Mitchell is the most equipped to fill in and produce. He’s not a pick for the immediate future and might not realize his full value until his second contract. The talent grade is strong, but the fit will require Anthony Richardson to support three receivers at a high level. He has the talent to develop into that QB but it’s a narrow margin for MItchell to reach his ceiling.

MarShawn Lloyd
Pre-Draft
Lloyd’s position at the bottom of the second tier among running backs stems primarily from his persistent issues with ball security, averaging a fumble once every 48.9 touches. This deficiency significantly impacts his overall grade, with potential improvement offering a modest boost of 2-6 points, contingent on the extent of enhancement.
His high rate of fumbling raises legitimate concerns regarding his future trajectory, mirroring the setbacks experienced by previous players such as Stevan Ridley and Ameer Abdullah. However, it’s worth noting that collegiate fumbling doesn’t always foreshadow performance in the NFL, as evidenced by Sony Michell’s transition.
While Lloyd’s ball security remains a glaring weakness, his underlying talent is undeniable. Although stylistically compared to Deangelo Williams, he falls short in areas like decision-making and scheme proficiency. Nevertheless, he demonstrates prowess in breaking tackles, receiving, and pass protection, hinting at potential as a lead back if he can address his ball security issues.
Despite his undeniable skill set, Lloyd’s persistent struggles with ball security prevent him from ascending higher in the rankings. Nevertheless, his abilities as a runner and blocker make him a viable candidate for a committee role in the NFL, with room for development into a more prominent position given improvement in this critical aspect of his game.
Ceiling?
Lead back of a committee.
Floor?
Reserve with a fumbling problem
Post-Draft
If Lloyd can’t beat Dillon by season’s end, maturity will be a big question-mark or the light came back on for Dillon. Lloyd will be the heir-apparent if he performs well this year.
Lloyd has a lot of Aaron Jones’ qualities but the most important ones–mature decision-making and ball security–need work.

Thaifighter

Marvin Harrison Jr.
Pre-Draft
Nabers and Odunze have emerged as formidable contenders, potentially surpassing Harrison in some draft evaluations. However, Harrison remains a promising prospect expected to contribute significantly to his team. While Harrison’s production and highlight-reel plays may suggest he’s a primary option, his dynamic route running and ball carrying fall short compared to Nabers and Odunze. Despite his skills in tracking the ball and contested catches, Harrison’s pass-catching technique is flawed in specific scenarios, leading to unexpected drops. However, these issues are not universal across all targets, suggesting that panic over his potential is unwarranted. Yet, it’s essential to acknowledge these concerns and potentially leverage them in trade negotiations.
Although Harrison lacks the explosive agility of Nabers or Odunze, he compensates with his ability to win late in vertical routes and create mismatches against off-coverage. His release game against press-man coverage requires refinement, particularly in minimizing wasted movement and countering defensive tactics. Harrison’s skill set makes him a valuable asset against substantial cushions but vulnerable against tight coverage from elite NFL cornerbacks. Additionally, his default catching technique, reminiscent of McLaurin and Harrison Sr., poses risks of dropped passes in the professional arena.
Despite these concerns, Harrison possesses numerous strengths as a pass catcher, excelling in concentration and contested scenarios. His potential as a boundary option is undeniable, although comparisons to Mike Williams may overlook Williams’ superior athleticism and ball security. Nonetheless, Harrison’s immediate impact as a starter is anticipated, given his playmaking ability and capacity to generate big plays. However, any struggles with his technique could limit his early career trajectory, akin to a more dynamic Corey Davis hampered by errors compared to Mike Williams.
Ceiling?
Harrison either corrects his pass-catching flaws or proves that he’s exceptional enough to win at this level with suboptimal technique and he becomes what we thought Corey Davis would become as the fifth-overall pick of the Titans.
Floor?
The narrower margin for error with NFL coverage leads to Harrison dropping more passes than anticipated and he experiences more difficulties with separating and earning position with contested vertical targets. If this happens, Harrison could perform more like Courtland Sutton, a good NFL player, but a starter whose team must feed him a little more than top options to get commensurate production.
Post-Draft
Harrison has the best veteran quarterback right now and will be the primary option outside against top cornerbacks who will exploit some of Harrison’s faults that weren’t as exploitable by college corners. Still, he has enough surrounding talent to produce early.
If the Giants land a good QB next year, Harrison could go from having the best NFL QB of the three to the worst. I don’t think Harrison will be a bust, but it’s important to know he’s not immune to mediocre productivity.

Jayden Daniels
Pre-Draft
Daniels exhibits qualities reminiscent of Lamar Jackson, particularly in his build, mobility, speed, and arm talent. However, a comprehensive comparison reveals disparities between Daniels and Jackson’s game, especially in their proficiency within various offensive schemes. While Jackson thrived in a system that allowed him to progress through reads effectively, Daniels has shown limitations in this aspect, often struggling with timing and patience on multiple-read plays.
Similar to Dak Prescott’s college experience, Daniels may require a scheme tailored to his strengths, prioritizing quick decisions and gradual progression reads. Without the support of an experienced infrastructure or time on the bench for development, like Jordan Love had, Daniels’ growth may be hindered.
To maximize his potential, Daniels needs to enhance his pocket management skills and develop a better understanding of when routes will break open based on defensive coverage. Failure to do so could result in susceptibility to complex game plans and hinder his progression as a passer.
Nevertheless, Daniels possesses physical upside and dynamic mobility, coupled with maturity as a game manager. While he may currently lack refinement in finding open receivers, the appeal lies in his potential to develop into a more polished passer with the right coaching and experience.
Ceiling?
What we saw from Love in 2023 with the Packers if Daniels earns a true development timeline behind the scenes.
Floor?
A one-contract starter who flames out before that first contract expires.
Post-Draft
Daniels could thrive statistically with Kingsbury but the advantage with WR talent he had at LSU won’t create the same advantage he’ll have in the NFL and it means he’ll have to be a sharper processor of information and more confident. Daniels will earn rushing yards but he’s at his best on play designs as a runner. He’s at his best as a passer in schemed designs that embed reads more as misdirection rather than require him to create with his reading prowess.

Keon Coleman
Pre-Draft
Coleman’s evaluation delves into nuanced considerations, particularly regarding his fit within an offensive system and the capabilities of his quarterback. While he demonstrates exceptional contested-catch ability and effective route running, unlocking his full potential hinges on having a quarterback with precise anticipation and confidence in tight-window throws.
Despite his unimpressive 40-time, Coleman showcases impressive play speed, often gaining separation early in routes and outmaneuvering defenders. His sharp breaks and ability to stack defenders position him as a viable intermediate target, especially when targeted as the primary option. However, if relegated to secondary or tertiary reads, Coleman’s effectiveness diminishes, particularly against tight man coverage.
Coleman’s contested-catch prowess and physicality partially compensate for quarterback shortcomings, but his ranking reflects a boom-bust dynamic dependent on his ability to reach his NFL ceiling. Nevertheless, his ceiling is notable, characterized by a vast catch radius and unwavering confidence in contested situations.
Additionally, Coleman’s agility and versatility extend beyond receiving duties, as evidenced by his success as a punt returner at FSU. His adeptness at changing direction efficiently and navigating tight spaces highlights his multifaceted skill set, leading to comparisons with LeGarrette Blount, whose perception as a “plodding athlete” belied his effectiveness in various roles, including kick return duties.
A potential fit with the Steelers is highlighted, given Coleman’s high effort, blocking acumen, and resemblance to Russell Wilson’s former teammate Tim Patrick. Coleman’s attributes make him a desirable addition, offering a dynamic presence reminiscent of Patrick, albeit with added versatility and potential for impact.
Ceiling?
Coleman could have a career similar to Anquan Boldin, Mike Williams, or maybe Brandon Marshall if his route skills carry over and find the right fit with a good quarterback.
Floor?
Coleman becomes a third option in an offense or an off-the-bench option who is only used situationally because a GM drafted Coleman into an offensive system with a coach who doesn’t see a fit and tries to make Coleman be something he isn’t.
Post-Draft
Coleman has a slightly lower floor than the receivers above him as a yardage and reception compiler but not as low as many expect. He also has a high ceiling for TDs. Coleman has multiple avenues to deliver a starter-level fit in the Bills offense as an outside and/or inside receiver. Think of him as a more realized Gabriel Davis in every facet.

Bo Nix
Pre-Draft
Nix’s quarterback profile is marked by his arm limitations, which differentiate him from higher-ranked prospects like Michael Penix, Jr. While possessing enough arm strength for NFL systems, it falls short of elite levels seen in quarterbacks like Drew Brees or Tom Brady, limiting his ability to power through late or questionable decisions. However, this shouldn’t dissuade teams from viewing him as a potential future starter.
Contrary to the perception of him as a product of college systems, Nix demonstrates traits beyond scheme reliance. His accuracy, technical proficiency, pocket management, and decision-making indicate starter potential. Despite Auburn’s receiver issues, Nix showcased adept field reading, leveraging defenders’ positions with precise target decisions.
Additionally, Nix exhibits manipulative skills, utilizing frame positioning, play fakes, and pump fakes to influence defenders. While lacking top-tier arm strength, he compensates with anticipation, delivering vertical shots effectively when reading accurately. However, late throws can result in receivers waiting for the ball, exposing them to NFL defenses.
Although Nix occasionally relies heavily on pocket escape maneuvers, he displays efficient pocket climbs and nimble footwork to evade pressure. While not as dynamic as some quarterbacks, he possesses enough mobility to extend plays and create opportunities downfield.
Nix’s maturity shines in decision-making, demonstrated by his willingness to throw away plays rather than forcing risky passes. Maintaining this level of maturity in the NFL could lead to mistake-free football early in his career, especially with a strong supporting infrastructure.
While starting as a rookie for a rebuilding team might pose challenges, Nix could provide moderate production with minimal critical errors if surrounded by the right talent and coaching. His ability to navigate pressure, make off-platform throws, and prioritize ball security underscore his potential to develop into a reliable NFL starter given the right circumstances.
Ceiling?
If Nix can maximize his decision-making potential and land with receivers who excel at timing routes, Nix could become a productive starter with top-15 production potential at his position. He’ll need a stacked offense and a top-notch offensive coach to deliver top-five production.
Floor?
Nix experiences difficulty reading the field as he’s acclimating to the NFL game, takes a lot of punishment, and his game deteriorates to the point that he loses confidence and too many throws are late and questionable decisions.
Post-Draft
Nix may have to survive a difficult season but he’s mature enough that he might manage it and still thrive in 2-3 seasons.
Nix has the ceiling to be a lot of what Mitchell Trubisky could have been with better game management and leverage reading.

Old Town ROME(AN)

Rome Odunze
Pre-Draft
Odunze stands out as the premier athlete among the top receivers in a highly touted class, boasting the ideal physical attributes sought by NFL decision-makers for a primary receiver. While he may not match Nabers’ level of technical refinement as a route runner, Odunze’s skills are still polished enough to yield immediate production with room for further growth.
Though he hasn’t consistently executed his preferred release combinations with optimal patience and suddenness, Odunze has made strides in this aspect, displaying several combinations executed with the necessary artistry. His proficiency in hand violence at the line of scrimmage sets him apart from many receivers.
Even when faced with jams, Odunze exhibits quick counters to get into his routes, showcasing an ability to win even when the defender gains an early advantage. Like Nabers, he understands how to manipulate opponents with pacing and angles during route stems, utilizing a repertoire of breaks sufficient for most routes.
With excellent body control and tracking skills, Odunze excels at making clutch catches in crucial moments, displaying sound technique and selection appropriate for each pass trajectory. His post-catch ability further adds to his value, as he adeptly navigates pursuit angles and evades defenders with patience, footwork, and lateral explosiveness.
Overall, Odunze’s combination of athleticism, technical proficiency, and clutch playmaking ability positions him as a top receiver prospect, capable of developing into a team’s primary option within the first few years of his NFL career.
Ceiling?
Top-five producer at his position at various points of his career.
Floor?
An Amari Cooper type who paces his offense and earns top-15 or top-20 production most seasons that he’s healthy but isn’t paired with an offense or quarterback to earn elite volume.
Post-Draft
If you make Odunze you’re WR1, I have no qualms with it. If you’re expecting him to equal Harrison or Nabers as a rookie producer, that may prove unrealistic if all three are healthy because Odunze has the most competition for targets.
Odunze can work all three receiver positions at all three levels. Like Nabers, he’s adept against press, handles physical play well at the catch point, and wins after the catch. He’s more physical than Nabers as well. He’s in a great opportunity to learn and level up fast and paired with a quarterback who can complement his skills.

Michael Penix Jr.
Pre-Draft
Penix presents a complex evaluation due to his injury history, which includes two ACL tears and shoulder injuries, potentially deterring teams from viewing him as an early-round prospect despite his impressive showing at the NFL Combine. Quarterbacks selected early often land on rebuilding teams with struggling offensive lines, where they may miss early opportunities, facing pressure and hits that could affect their long-term trajectory.
However, Penix’s proven toughness and ability to lead Washington to a National Championship title appearance after overcoming significant injuries could sway some teams to overlook concerns about his durability. Nevertheless, his age, having spent six seasons in college football, may raise red flags for teams favoring younger prospects.
Another challenge in evaluating Penix is Washington’s offensive scheme, which limits opportunities for high-end decision-making seen in pro-style offenses. Despite this, Penix has shown improvement in reading leverage, displaying NFL-caliber anticipation and placement, particularly against crowded zones in the middle of the field.
Critics have questioned Penix’s comfort under pressure, but he demonstrates efficiency as a mover under pressure, capable of making quick adjustments to find open receivers. While there are concerns about certain throws not working at the NFL level, Penix’s smart decision-making is trending positively.
Penix’s best-case scenario involves being paired with a team that allows him time to develop and build infrastructure that maximizes his strengths. While he may not possess the same athleticism as some of his peers, his fearless and accurate vertical throwing style, reminiscent of Warren Moon, could prove valuable with continued refinement.
Despite enduring significant hits at Indiana, Penix maintained solid decision-making, suggesting potential for further growth with improved footwork and conceptual understanding of defenses. Given the NFL’s recent limitations on the vertical passing game, Penix’s strengths may not hold the same value, but his ability to protect the ball and make sound decisions bodes well for his potential as an NFL starter with the right development track and infrastructure.
Ceiling?
If Penix earns the Jordan Love treatment or develops faster than expected, he could become a franchise starter—especially if paired with excellent one-on-one receivers who get open fast and/or win at the boundary.
Floor?
Penix fails to become a well-rounded decision-maker or can’t stay healthy and the NFL decides he’s not worth the investment as more than a journeyman backup.
Post-Draft
First-round QBs fail 67 percent of the time. The best developmental scenarios for NFL QBs include time on the bench early in their career and working along side a veteran starter. Penix has both dynamics and, between the ears, Penix is the most promising processor and best arm talent after Caleb Williams.
If you look at the failure rate for QBs and the type of players that fail, it’s usually the “upside” physical talents who play too early. Penix is a physical talent, but not considered the upside play due to narratives that lack validity.

Ben Sinnott
Pre-Draft
Sinnott, initially a walk-on at Kansas State, mirrors the physical attributes and athletic prowess of T.J. Hockenson, boasting quicker 40-yard dash and 3-cone times, along with a superior vertical leap. Despite not garnering the same media attention as standout tight end Michael Mayer, Sinnott possesses notable acceleration and size, albeit lacking top-end long speed to consistently threaten cornerbacks downfield.
His adeptness at release footwork and hand counters against off-coverage, especially on shallow routes, demonstrates promising technique and efficient weight distribution. While he exhibits strengths at the catch point and after receptions, Sinnott’s potential as a primary offensive weapon hinges on further development in executing intermediate routes.
Sinnott’s agility and explosiveness enable him to excel in high-pointing passes and maintaining balance to secure targets. Nonetheless, refinement in hand placement for attacking passes, particularly under duress, remains an area for improvement. Despite this, his ability to force defenders into gang-tackling situations post-catch showcases deceptive toughness and agility in evading tackles.
In run-blocking scenarios, Sinnott’s proficiency as a lead blocker is evident, although he remains a work in progress in executing blocks while lined up. Despite potential concerns surrounding his collegiate program and walk-on status, Sinnott presents considerable upside for NFL teams and fantasy football enthusiasts, particularly if selected within the early rounds. For teams unable to secure top-tier prospects like Bowers or Stover, Sinnott represents an appealing low-risk, high-reward option with significant potential for growth and impact.
Ceiling?
T.J. Hockenson’s production.
Floor?
Mismatched in an offense as an in-line option and Michael Mayer’s rookie production is the norm.
Post-Draft
Sinnott has the skills to develop into a top producer in the passing game at his position if Kliff Kingsbuy’s scheme allows it.
Sinnott may have a better NFL career than fantasy career during his first contract. If he does, the second contract could be where the fantasy value comes into play.

Roman Wilson
Pre-Draft
Wilson possesses the athleticism and foundational skills to potentially emerge as a high-impact receiver in the future, though he may require a year or two of development before reaching his full potential. While he demonstrates explosiveness against tight man coverage, his release lacks the finesse and variety needed to consistently deceive defenders. Similarly, his route running could benefit from sharper breaks, particularly in intermediate areas where elite receivers thrive.
In terms of ball-catching ability, Wilson excels at high-pointing passes and tracking the ball over his shoulder. However, he occasionally struggles with targets at body height, displaying mixed hand positioning and a tendency to clap-attack the ball. Despite these inconsistencies, Wilson exhibits strong hands and the ability to secure catches in contested situations, even amidst heavy contact.
His agility and elusiveness are evident in his short-area movements, with effective jump cuts and stop-start motions allowing him to evade defenders and create yardage. While he lacks power as a runner, his stiff-arm and ability to drop his pads into contact provide some means of resistance against tackles. Overall, Wilson’s potential as a receiver lies in his athleticism and flashes of technical skill, but he will need refinement in various aspects of his game to maximize his impact at the next level.
Ceiling?
A Tyler Lockett clone if he improves his route running.
Floor?
A speedy situational threat who doesn’t grow past his limited route tree at Michigan.
Post-Draft
The Steelers have a reputation for strong mid-round picks but I’m not sure Wilson applies. He’s athletic but he’s unrefined against man coverage. With the question marks about who is starting at QB, who will Wilson mesh with most? Can he find a role immediately? Is there enough stability with the offense for Wilson not to get lost in the shuffle?

Team W.P.

Jonathon Brooks
Pre-Draft
Brooks, currently rehabbing an ACL tear suffered in November, faces a recovery timeline that could delay his return to peak physical condition by about a year. Given this injury and his limited experience as a starter, Brooks may see his draft stock fall to the range of rounds 3-5. However, his injury should not overshadow his remarkable talent and potential. Even with the injury, Brooks stands out as the top running back in this class, with the potential to rival last year’s standout Jahmyr Gibbs.
Despite his injury, Brooks moves on the field like a seasoned NFL veteran, showcasing exceptional agility and versatility in evading defenders and delivering or deflecting hits. He utilizes his 216-pound frame to power through contact, often shrugging off multiple tackles in a single play—a skill typically associated with top-tier NFL starters. Brooks’s ability to defeat linebacker hits and wraps is particularly impressive, reflecting his advanced understanding of contact dynamics and technique.
Drawing comparisons to Jamaal Charles, Brooks exhibits a maturity in his running style that belies his injury-induced acclimation period. He combines power and decision-making with exceptional acceleration and speed, capable of flipping the field and generating big plays consistently. Additionally, while his route running may not yet rival that of established backs like Austin Ekeler, Brooks shows promise as a reliable receiver out of the backfield, with strong hands and smooth catching ability.
Perhaps most notably, Brooks excels as a pass protector, displaying technical proficiency and keen awareness in identifying and neutralizing pressure. His all-around skill set makes him worth the investment for teams willing to provide him with a red-shirt season to fully recover from his injury. Despite the perception of this year’s running back class as weaker than previous years, Brooks’s talent and potential place him among the top prospects at the position, deserving of consideration as a high-value selection.
Ceiling?
Brooks isn’t as fast as Cadillac Williams was at Auburn, but his combination of smooth running in traffic and physicality is a good stylistic comparison. Another is a savvier and more athletic Melvin Gordon. Either way, that type of ability indicates top-10 statistical production as a starter as Brooks’ potential peak.
Floor?
Brooks fails to return fully from his ACL tear and has career as a reserve or mid-level contributor to a committee.
Post-Draft
Brooks has instant starter RB1 ability but lacks the proven infrastructure to rate him in the same post-draft tier as Bijan Robinson last year.
Brooks probably won’t be 100 percent at his athletic prowess until next year but he is expected to be healthy enough to compete this summer. If you understand this difference, you’ll have appropriate expectations for Brooks as a rookie.

Ricky Pearsall
Pre-Draft
Pearsall is an explosive athlete known for his big-play ability both as a ballcarrier and a vertical receiver. With a dynamic catch radius and toughness at the catch point, he can be a reliable target for a veteran quarterback on various routes, both over the middle and up the boundary. Similar to Chris Olave, Pearsall may not fit the mold of a typical primary weapon, but his comprehensive skill set allows him to function effectively as a primary or secondary option in many offenses.
One of Pearsall’s standout qualities is his ability to deliver sharp breaks, a critical skill against tight man-to-man coverage in the NFL. This precision will serve him well on in- and out-breaking routes, where every movement can determine the success of a play. His rapport with quarterbacks, as evidenced by his performance with Anthony Richardson, highlights his ability to excel in high-pressure situations and adapt to various scenarios.
Pearsall’s athletic profile and release techniques suggest he will adapt quickly to press coverage, potentially surprising many cornerbacks in his rookie season. His post-catch abilities will also challenge defensive backs, who may initially underestimate his patience and lateral quickness.
At the catch point, Pearsall employs all the necessary techniques to secure the ball, often with a flair for the spectacular. While he occasionally makes suboptimal decisions in specific scenarios, these lapses are rare and not indicative of a recurring issue.
Due to the depth of talent in this receiver class, Pearsall might be drafted lower than his skill set warrants, making him a potential steal. This undervaluation echoes the underestimation he might face from NFL cornerbacks early in his career. Compared to other receivers like Ladd McConkey, Pearsall offers a distinct set of strengths, underscoring the importance of recognizing his unique abilities rather than making direct comparisons.
Ceiling?
Chris Olave-Chad Johnson territory as a high-volume target who also offers big plays as a vertical receiver before and after the catch.
Floor?
Pearsall gets miscast in a WR3-WR4 role, but this isn’t the early 2000s where coaches wrote off white wide receivers.
Post-Draft
Pearsall would be good first-round pick with instant fantasy value if Samuel or Aiyuk were already gone. Now, it’s iffy and the downside Year 1 is no fantasy value as a low-volume slot/reserve outside option. If you’re playing the long-game, Pearsall is worth a second-round pick.
The 49ers play a lot of 12 personnel and 22 personnel which means Samuel and Aiyuk are the only two receivers on the field. Even a midseason trade could force Pearsall to play catch-up and limit his readiness.

Troy Franklin
Pre-Draft
Franklin is an elite speedster with excellent acceleration and quickness in changing direction. He has proven release skills at the line of scrimmage and effectively stacks defenders to win in the vertical game. While he can improve his route stems to enhance his route running, he already uses efficient setups at the top of the stem to gain separation, which should continue to be effective against NFL defenders.
Despite occasional issues with clap-attacks on timing routes, which can lead to drops, Franklin is generally a reliable pass tracker and catcher. He can make difficult plays, though not as consistently or at as high a level as the best pass-catchers in the draft. If he did, he might be compared to Paul Richardson, who showed potential to match peak Antonio Brown’s play-making efficiency during his time with the Seahawks. However, Franklin falls just short of that level as a pass tracker and catcher.
Still, Franklin’s skills are of starting quality. After the catch, he is elusive, patient, and possesses a physical finishing ability reminiscent of Richardson and Williams, with surprising contact balance for his size. Franklin has the potential to develop into a starting split end in the NFL within 1-2 seasons and, if he fully develops his route-running game, he could become a Pro-Bowl talent.
Ceiling?
Pro-Bowl producer
Floor?
Situational deep threat and return specialist.
Post-Draft
If Franklin proves his route skills translate well, he could outperform his draft-day value. Sean Payton has never been afraid of using undersized receivers. Lance Moore comes to mind.

Kimani Vidal
Pre-Draft
Vidal, similar in build and strengths to D’Andre Swift, exhibits impressive versatility and intelligence as a runner. Though their grades are close, Vidal would edge out Swift due to his smarter running decisions. Unlike many backs with his size, speed, and quickness, Vidal manages risk well, especially in critical situations like the red zone or deep in his own territory.
He excels in both gap and zone blocking schemes, though he shows a slight preference for gap running. Vidal’s low center of gravity and dynamic movement allow him to execute a variety of jump stops and jump-cuts, efficiently transitioning downhill and beating defenders through creases or around the edge. While he runs upright between tackles, reducing the benefit of his size, he effectively sheds tackles from linemen and linebackers.
Vidal surpasses Swift in power and blocking ability, though he needs minor improvements in his receiving technique. His route running at Troy was basic, limiting his exposure to more complex plays. Despite this, Vidal’s promise on film is evident, but his experience in the SBC conference rather than the SEC might hinder his draft capital prospects. This is significant as Swift benefited from the prestige of playing for Georgia, while Vidal might face tougher competition and political hurdles in training camps.
Overall, Vidal has the power and contact balance to be a reliable interior runner, at least in a committee role. If he can add 8-10 pounds without losing his athleticism, he has the potential to transcend a committee role and become a feature back if given the opportunity.
Ceiling?
A feature back who can deliver on all four-down downs, but the odds of reaching this tier is remote due to the nature of the NFL. He could earn a lead role in a committee for a year or two and depending on his health and the strength of future classes, we’ll see if he keeps it or is made the second option to a new teammate with higher draft capital and more feature back promise.
Floor?
A reserve with limited contributions behind players with higher draft capital.
Post-Draft
Dobbins Achilles injury could open the door for Vidal to have an early role and Vidal is talented enough to become a rookie contributor. Vidal is one of the best 2-3 RB values in rookie drafts. Vidal is a low-cost, high-upside pick with reason to believe the upside is realistic this year as a productive committee option.

Motor City Dynasty

Caleb Williams
Pre-Draft
Williams shows flashes of quarterback virtuosity that suggest he could become an elite game-changer for his team. Comparisons to Patrick Mahomes are common due to their shared technical and conceptual skills, especially in their creative field vision and unconventional release techniques. However, it’s important to recognize the nuances that set them apart.
Media comparisons have often been misleading, such as likening Mahomes to less successful quarterbacks like Zach Wilson and Drew Lock. This stems from a misunderstanding of Mahomes’ game, which was evident even before his NFL success. Mahomes’ success isn’t solely due to his supporting cast; his unique skills and creative play style were often underestimated. Mahomes’ footwork and quick processing are influenced by his background in baseball, contributing to his NFL success. Many analysts failed to appreciate these subtleties, focusing instead on traditional quarterback mechanics.
Williams, while compared to Mahomes, has notable differences. His inaccuracies often stem from lazy footwork and an overreliance on his arm talent. He sometimes takes unnecessary sacks and bypasses easy reads in favor of big plays, showing a tendency toward risky decisions. His dynamic movements can disrupt his receivers’ routes and create extra pressure on his linemen, similar to issues seen with Kyler Murray.
Murray’s career highlights the potential pitfalls for Williams. Despite Murray’s talent, his inefficient pocket management has led to mixed results. Like Murray, Williams risks becoming a replaceable talent if he doesn’t refine his technical and conceptual skills. Williams’ success will depend heavily on his landing spot in the NFL. A strong team infrastructure can significantly impact a quarterback’s development, as seen with Brock Purdy on the 49ers compared to Mac Jones on the Patriots.
Quarterbacks need a supportive environment to thrive, and without it, their college strengths can deteriorate under NFL pressure. Williams’ potential downside is landing with a poorly managed team that fails to develop his skills. However, his upside is immense. Williams often displays efficient, intelligent football, climbing the pocket effectively and reading defenses well. His ability to learn from mistakes and his creativity off-structure are promising traits.
Williams’ game combines dynamic athleticism, precise football placement, and innovative playmaking, reminiscent of Aaron Rodgers at his best. While not identical to Mahomes, Williams possesses a similar realm of talent with a unique flair. His future success hinges on refining his weaknesses and finding the right NFL environment to nurture his elite potential.
Ceiling?
An NFL passing leader who will be a significant reason his team is a perennial contender.
Floor?
A skilled passer who hasn’t become a consistent, well-rounded quarterback and his moments of inefficiency and hubris cost his team downs, drives, and enough games that he’s eventually considered replaceable.
Post-Draft
Williams is not necessarily man-child proof in terms of team executives/owners/coaches making the developmental environment difficult but it appears the Bears have learned some lessons after failing Fields in this area.

Ladd McConkey
Pre-Draft
This year’s Cinderella of draft media, Ladd McConkey, has drawn comparisons to Cooper Kupp, but he more closely resembles an aspiring slot version of Tyler Lockett, minus the proven contested-catch ability along the vertical boundary that Lockett showcased at Kansas State. While McConkey has the speed to succeed in the vertical game, he hasn’t demonstrated consistent success in contested catches along the boundary, largely because this wasn’t his role at Georgia. Evaluators should adopt a “prove it” approach regarding this aspect of his game.
McConkey’s footwork in release packages is commendable, but his hand techniques need improvement. He tends to paw at defenders rather than using the necessary violence and timing to win these battles. This is a significant difference from Kupp, who excels at using his hands and feet before and after the catch. McConkey’s selection of techniques is also suboptimal at times, leading to him getting hung up on specific releases.
These issues aren’t fatal flaws but do limit his current versatility and danger as a player. Without improvement in these areas, his ceiling as an outside receiver may be limited. McConkey’s vertical game is most effective when he’s running double moves or working from the slot and making angled breaks to the intermediate or vertical boundary. Defenders quickly learn that he has a strong arsenal of underneath breaks, allowing him to earn separation by baiting them before accelerating past.
McConkey’s deep weight drop helps him create separation on routes breaking back to the quarterback and during double moves. This skill, combined with his patience and expertise in setting up defenders and using blockers, makes him a strong runner in both traffic and open field situations. However, he needs to clean up minor details as a pass catcher to avoid limiting his game. For instance, he sometimes uses suboptimal attacks against coverage playing behind him, leading to drops when hit at the catch point, and he often leaves his feet when the ball is on his numbers, a tracking flaw indicating a lack of confidence in ball trajectory.
Overall, McConkey is a technically sound ball attacker in most scenarios and can make plays against contact. He has the potential to be a productive slot-flanker with big-play capabilities in play-action scenarios and as a ballcarrier on RPOs, screens, and routes crossing zones. While his game isn’t as complete as Kupp’s, McConkey has enough similarities to merit comparisons and could potentially fill a similar role in the NFL.
Ceiling?
A Kupp-like role.
Floor?
A plus-version of Kyle Phillips in an offense that doesn’t lean hard enough on the slot receiver in the passing game.
Post-Draft
McConkey is a good RPO/screen play with strong enough double moves to win the deep seam or boundary off play-action. If he proves capable with his hands to fend off press, he could join the same tier as the Big Three on the basis of ability.

Jaylen Wright
Pre-Draft
Wright could easily develop into the best back in this class. This is not what I would have thought six months ago, but Wright’s game and potential grew on me as I saw more of his film. Backs usually earn lower scores and additional doubt when they are prone to bouncing plays outside despite logical play designs inside. Wright’s speed and decisive nature compensates for this, allowing him to bounce runs for gains and breakaway runs effectively.
Wright won’t dominate on speed and acceleration alone in the NFL. He’ll need to take advantage of tight, well-blocked interior gaps to succeed as he did in college. Despite needing to learn more, Wright shows skill between the tackles, setting up lead blockers, and moving middle linebackers into blocks—something less disciplined runners struggle with. This gives him more potential than Tevin Coleman displayed at Indiana and throughout his career.
Wright’s movement is a standout aspect of his game, with strong stop-start skills, efficient hip mobility, and diverse footwork that sets up creases and makes defenders miss in space. He excels at getting his feet and knees high to work through reaches and wraps, reminiscent of Alvin Kamara, especially with his ability to extricate his lower legs from wraps by kicking his heels to his backside. However, unlike Kamara, Wright is not an elite contact-runner and has areas to improve in pass protection and receiving. Depending on his ability to learn, Wright could quickly become a dependable weapon in the passing game.
Like Tony Pollard, Wright has an explosive game that can initially produce well and garner hype in less conceptually demanding scenarios. Over time, he could develop to take on the role of a lead runner in the NFL.
Ceiling?
Lead runner and every-down back.
Floor?
Space player in a committee with limited value between the tackles.
Post-Draft
Wright’s expertise meshes well with the Miami system and won’t require much maturation as a decision-maker to thrive.
Look for Wright to play the Mostert role by 2025 with Achane as the complement. Think of it as Mr. Inside/Mr. Outside with out the Dolphins stretch the field–even if that’s a bit simplistic with how it will play out.

Dirty Dan

Brock Bowers
Pre-Draft
Bowers is a top 5-6 option and could be a top-three overall selection in a 1.5 PPR format. Bowers should be viewed similarly to Sam LaPorta, a move tight end known for his receiving and running abilities. While LaPorta’s game is an advanced iteration of Evan Engram’s, Bowers’ game resembles Vernon Davis with a mix of Aaron Hernandez’s versatility.
If we could separate Hernandez the football player from his off-field issues, his skills would be highly praiseworthy. Bowers has a similar physical package and could be utilized similarly. Athletically, Bowers may rival Davis, who was a standout at the NFL Combine with impressive metrics such as a 4.38-second 40-yard dash and a 42-inch vertical. Davis, the sixth overall pick in his draft, had a 14-year career with notable achievements despite some inconsistencies.
Bowers didn’t participate in workouts this spring, so comparisons to Davis’ athleticism are based on film. Bowers has star potential but hasn’t shown a wide variety of release moves due to defenses not playing tight coverage against him. His size, speed, and acceleration make him a mismatch for most defenders. Bowers has effective route setups, especially with vertical-breaking patterns, and his footwork is sharper with intermediate patterns.
Bowers offers dynamic and reliable hands in most receiving scenarios, with strong boundary work, back-shoulder game, and the ability to take contact. However, he struggles with high-point targets, often fighting the ball. Overall, Bowers has soft hands and excellent hand-eye coordination for making tough catches.
After the catch, Bowers excels with quick, precise footwork, efficient acceleration, and a feel for eliminating pursuit angles. He bounces off hits from defenders and uses his momentum to gain extra yardage. Bowers is an excellent option for screens and routes breaking across the field due to his quickness and decision-making.
Bowers is expected to have an immediate impact in the NFL. Most teams will utilize him effectively, avoiding missteps in his role. While his blocking is technically sound, he’s undersized for certain assignments. Teams will likely use him strategically, taking advantage of his strengths as a receiver and runner.
Bowers has earned the highest grade in the RSP since the refinement of tight end evaluation techniques. He’s a franchise-caliber player to build around, offering significant value to any NFL offense.
Ceiling?
Perennial top-five tight end in receiving production with multiple seasons as the league leader who resets the standard for elite receiving stats.
Floor?
The team that drafts Bowers has a coach-GM-ownership dysfunction that leads to the executive group force-feeding Bowers to a coach who wanted an in-line tight end and that coach, just to prove a point, forces Bowers to play a role he can’t physically perform and stalls, if not ruins, Bowers’ career. This is unlikely, but still possible.
Post-Draft
Gardner Minshew and Aidan O’Connell are unlikely the long-term answer at QB for the Raiders, but Minshew is capable of feeding Bowers enough to generate productive volume.
Long-term, Bowers is the best bet in the Raiders’ passing game and he offers elite production potential at his position. Paired with a top quarterback, Bowers could deliver fantasy WR1 production in a TE1 role.

Xavier Worthy
Pre-Draft
Worthy is a polarizing prospect. Critics argue he is merely a deep threat with a record-setting 40-yard dash time of 4.21 seconds and a 41-inch vertical, raising concerns about his hands, effort, and 165-pound frame. They doubt his ability to provide consistent production and reliability to justify a top-five selection in this strong receiver class.
However, Worthy’s top-five ranking in this class by some evaluators suggests there’s more to his game than just speed. He does have flaws, such as inconsistent hands, less-than-ideal snap in his breaks, and spacing issues on vertical routes. His blocking near the line of scrimmage is also subpar. Despite these issues, his game offers much more than just explosive athleticism.
Worthy excels at making difficult catches, tracking the ball well even with his back to it, and showing toughness at the catch point, similar to Isaac Bruce and DeSean Jackson. Despite his size, he wins targets against hard contact and at the boundary. His speed and quickness contribute to his ability to pull through tackles and bounce off hits, much like Jamaal Charles did as a running back. Worthy’s aggressive running style, combined with his speed, allows him to attack defenses and minimize contact.
His weight drop into hard breaks helps him earn separation against tight coverage, a skill that fuels his double moves and vertical routes. Worthy also shows promise as a route runner against zone coverage and should develop the ability to read defenses well in the NFL.
If Worthy reaches his potential, he could follow the developmental path of Bruce and Jackson, both of whom were great primary options with dangerous deep games. Even if he falls short of that tier, he still has the skills to achieve what Titus Young briefly showed or what K.J. Hamler was projected to become.
In summary, Worthy is more than just a speedster. His ability to make tough catches, his fearless play style, and his potential as a route runner make him a compelling prospect despite his flaws. If he can refine his game, he has the potential to become a significant offensive weapon in the NFL.
Ceiling?
Many believe Devonta Smith is a primary receiver. He’s a good starter capable of primary receiver stats thanks to A.J. Brown’s presence. Worthy has the floor to be what Smith has been in the NFL and the ceiling to be what the general public incorrectly perceives him to be.
Floor?
Worthy’s hands fail him more often in the NFL and he fails to address the issue adequately enough to elevate his game beyond a 2020’s version of Ted Ginn, Jr.
Post-Draft
Worthy’s ball skills are better than advertised. I am high on Worthy and believe he can fulfill the hopes the Chiefs have had in numerous players over the past 6-8 years. The offense may require a lot from him that could slow his development like the others, but I think he has the best chance to learn and produce even learn fast. Think DeSean Jackson in Andy Reid’s offense in Philadelphia. That’s the aspirational fit and not as far away as you may think.


Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

More from Wolf Pack Dynasty