The 2023 Rookie Draft has come and passed. It will be remember as the first of hopefully many to come. It’s the one time a year that everyone can get together and talk shop as we throw darts on hopeful NFL players.
As we move forward to summer OTAs and preseason workouts, it becomes time to slowly put the results in to perspective. Some teams had clear agendas in the draft while others seemed to fly by the seat of their pants.
In this article, I’ll take a deeper dive into each team’s draft, evaluating and grading each pick, giving an overall grade. I’m really big about picking for value rather than need, especially in the first round. No need to reach for someone when there’s probably a guy later in the draft who’ll meet the same production. I’ll bring up the idea of ADP (average draft position) to determine whether the pick was a reach or a steal. Of course, it must be said, this is completely an opinion piece based on the research I’ve done. In a year or two, I could be completely right…or completely full of shit. That’s just sports baby!
Below is the complete results of the draft:

League’s 1st Dynasty (1.01, 2.01, 3.01)
Saddled with the first pick in the first draft, and the subsequent first picks in each round, Manu had two clear choices. Either trade down or pick Bijan Robinson. If you pick anyone besides Bijan, you might as well just light your entry fees on fire. Manu made a couple last second attempts to find trade suitors but to no avail.
Pick 1.01 – ATL RB Bijan Robinson (GRADE: A)

The clear cut choice by far this year, Bijan will be added to a strong running back group in Manu’s roster. Sitting at a stout 5’11 220, Bijan will dominate fantasy lineups for years to come. He’s the only current running back that remotely touches Saquon Barkley’s tier of talent. Not only does he have the generational talent but he also got drafted to one of the most favorable teams to use said talent. This pick gets a resounding A.
Pick 2.01 – BUF TE Dalton Kincaid (GRADE: A)
Arguably the best tight end in this year’s draft and Manu able to pick him up to start the second round. He doesn’t have an eye popping profile similar to some other prospects in his class, but he does go to a pass happy team with a bonafide franchise quarterback and his main competition for targets after near 30 year old Stefon Diggs is Gabe Davis…yawn. Kincaid is probably a dude and he’ll have no excuses to start the year.
Pick 3.01 – DET TE Sam LaPorta (GRADE: A)
Manu doubles up on tight end this year and why not? This is a great class in that position and LaPorta only adds to it. He’s a good not great athlete who was productive as a senior. It’s hard telling how high his ceiling is, but when you can get a guy who’ll be featured in one of the league’s most potent offenses right off the bat, in the third round, I struggle not giving this pick an A.
Overall Draft Grade: A
Team Dirty Dan (1.02, 2.02, 3.02)
I will preface this by saying that the second pick, this year, was the hardest decision to make. For much of the offseason, it was expected that this spot belonged to the likes of Bryce Young or C.J. Stroud. However, after a stunning combine and high draft capital, Anthony Richardson shot up draft boards, creating a three-way monster of a decision. Going into the draft, Dan was in need of a quarterback who could be saddled in his superflex position. Along with that, he also had a ton of uncertainty within his running back group.
Pick 1.02 – IND QB Anthony Richardson (GRADE: A)

Richardson is the ultimate boom or bust quarterback. He is extremely likely to not be good at passing footballs. He is extremely likely to be really good at running with the football. The running part gives him a high floor, but the passing part gives him a low ceiling. The biggest hope is that under the right circumstances, he can develop into a Josh Allen-type. However, Josh was a dime a dozen so that idea is really far fetched. I would make a solid bet that Richardson will at least give you one top 10 season, however, time will tell if he’s able to pass an average NFL efficiency. The pick gets an A because it fills a need and fits within ADP.
Pick 2.02 – TEN QB Will Levis (GRADE: B)
Look, Levis is probably bad, but he also might not be. Getting a QB who has 2nd round draft capital in the 2nd round of a rookie draft is a low-risk bet. The cost is so low, especially since Dan doesn’t really need him to be a world beater right out the gate. The film community loves his arm, mobility, and perceived “toughness”, and so did Tennessee. He’ll sit behind the corpse of Ryan Tannehill, at least to start the season, but it wouldn’t be surprising to see him gets some snaps, especially if the Titan offense is as putrid as expected. Pick would’ve gotten an A but I believe a need could’ve been filled with someone the likes of Zay Flowers.
Pick 3.02 – GB TE Luke Musgrave (GRADE: B)
Be big and freaky athletic and then also be drafted highly and you have my attention. Coming in at my #4 ranked TE, Musgrave will have a very clear path to playing time, but the biggest hindrance to true snap dominance, if anything, will be that Green Bay also decided to draft one of my favorite sleeper picks, Tucker Kraft. I’m assuming Green Bay plans to deploy a ton of two tight end sets, replicating something similar to that of New England in the early 2010s. Otherwise, it’ll be a true position battle to be the top tight end.
Overall Draft Grade: B+
Designated Drinkers (1.03 and 2.03)
With only two picks in his first rookie draft, Donny had to make them count. Similar to the 1.02, the 3rd pick pretty much was set up to take a quarterback. The biggest problem was that Donny’s team really wasn’t in dire need for another QB, but instead, probably a premier running back. Running back and tight end seemed to be the biggest holes in a fairly good roster.
Pick 1.03 – CAR QB Bryce Young (GRADE: A)

Overall number one pick in NFL draft meets the third pick in our rookie draft. Bryce is kind of like the polar opposite of Richardson. The dude can probably pass pretty well, but he is also not likely to run for much. His passing will keep him employed in the NFL long-term. People worry about his size but from what I saw in his college days, he knows how to avoid big contact. He plays safe, smart, and decisive. He knows how to win and he goes to a Frank Reich led Carolina offense now featuring Miles Sanders and new receivers, Jonathan Mingo and Adam Theilen. Pick gets an A because Donny followed the smart ADP and got the most valuable asset left on the board.
Pick 2.03 – BAL WR Zay Flowers (GRADE: A+)
As my only A+ grade in the entire draft, Zay Flowers as the 13th pick in the draft is insane. Don’t get me wrong, I don’t think he matches up with the talent of JSN, QJ, or Jordan Addison, but he’s still a better bet than some players picked before. The Ravens have a weird receiving core with a bunch of dudes who could be varying magnitudes of good with no sure things in the basket. Zay will likely find a role, but I’m unsure with how prominent it will be, couple that with a history of low pass volume and it gets a little murkier. Zay should find his way as a WR2 at some point in his career at the very least.
Overall Draft Grade: A
Team TheBasqueBastard (1.04, 2.04, 3.04)
The 1.04 is an interesting spot. Guaranteed the third choice in quarterback or the first non Bijan choice in either running back or receiver. Kaiet came into the draft similar to Dan by needing a solid superflex quarterback. He also could use help in both receiver and running back, so this was a perfect spot for him to find a mainstay in his lineup.
Pick 1.04 – LAC WR Quentin Johnston (GRADE: B)

First off, I have to say that Quentin Johnston was my favorite player in this years’ draft not named Bijan Robinson. This was before he hit the jackpot in terms of landing spot. You can’t ask for a better place to play than the friendly confines of SoFi stadium paired with a true gunslinging wunderkind in Justin Herbert and a pass happy coaching staff. The reasoning behind the B grade is because Kaiet skipped over three players who should’ve taken Johnston’s place. On first reaction, I was bewildered that Kaiet didn’t take the quarterback sitting in front of him or the running back that’ll surely be more productive early on. However, as I reflect more, the only thing I can think is that Johnston is such a stud that he’ll make the reach a non point within a couple years.
Pick 2.04 – KC WR Rashee Rice (GRADE: C)
I don’t mind going receiver here at this pick slot, however, there were at least three other dudes who I had above him still available. Unlike, Johnston, I don’t think Rice is a stud. Landing in KC is the tide that raises all boats… that being said, if Mahomes couldn’t make Mecole Hardman a thing… and then couldn’t make Kadarius and Skyy a thing…. then we might be holding out hope that bad players can be made good by situation which we know is generally not the case. Also, Rashee Rice could be good, but he probably isn’t as he wasn’t in college.
Pick 3.04 – DAL TE Luke Schoonmaker (GRADE: B+)
Quite honestly, I don’t know a ton about Schoonmaker but I do know he has a great athletic profile and he goes to a great fit in Dallas. He fits in as my TE5 in the draft. Getting picked in the second round, with a good chance to play heavily year one is always a good combination for fantasy relevance. I believe he’ll be a good IRL player but the jury is still out when it comes to fantasy ceiling. He gets the bump over the Musgrave pick two slots earlier due to the cleaner path for snap dominance.
Overall Draft Grade: B-
Motor City Dynasty (1.05, 2.06, 3.05)
Obviously I thought my draft was an A+++, but writing that wouldn’t be the best content. To make it a little more palatable, I graded myself as if I was in the shoes of a recently divorced high school english teacher. In other words, tough.
Coming into the draft, I felt I was in the best spot at #5, obviously besides the first pick. I knew I’d get a great prospect no matter how things fell.
Pick 1.05 – HOU QB C.J. Stroud (GRADE: A)

With Kaiet taking an early gamble on Quentin Johnston, that left the last first round quarterback, C.J. Stroud. There are few things more unbearable than the “Ohio State QBs narrative”, but we are seeing it yet again. With that said, Stroud is more or less a statue that can throw the ball well. Besides the size, I believe he and Bryce Young are very similar prospects and should be NFL starters for the next five years, at least. The biggest thing that hinders CJ’s fantasy outlook is the lack of true weapons in the Houston offense. In a clear rebuild, CJ will more than likely struggle to air things out, or even stay upright with a below average interior offensive line. However, the pick will get an A. Getting Stroud at the fifth spot is a gift and it fits an absolute need.
Pick 2.06 – JAX RB Tank Bigsby (GRADE: B)
Let me ask you, have you ever seen a running back named Tank fail? I rest my case. In all reality, Tank will be part of the one-two punch in the Jacksonville backfield. Despite his size, he’s a short yard and goal line specialist who has shown some pass catching abilities. There’s no question, at this point, that Travis Etienne is the main back, however, coach Doug Pederson has shown a propensity to use a running back by committee approach in a slightly pass happy offense. Grabbing Tank at this selection could be considered a reach in some arguments, hence, why I only gave this pick a B.
Pick 3.05 – DEN WR Marvin Mims (GRADE: A-)
Honestly don’t know how Mims made it this far in the draft. He was highly productive in college, and he’s a fantastic deep ball threat. It wouldn’t surprise me if he’s starting in the slot within the next two years. Of course, as of now, he’s kind of buried on the depth chart behind Judy, Sutton, and the returning Tim Patrick. He’s a long term project, which with my current roster construction, isn’t a big deal. However, I’ll give this pick an A- simply for the fact I could’ve grabbed Josh Downs who seemingly has a better chance at early production.
Overall Draft Grade: A-
Team Thaifighter (1.06 and 3.06)
Similar to Donny’s Designated Drinkers, Danny and Adam went into the draft with just two picks. Luckily, they still held the sixth pick, which allowed them to get a premier rookie. Thaifighter has a solid roster with premier talent across the board, so choosing between Jahmyr Gibbs and Jaxon Smith-Njigba was a complete toss up.
Pick 1.06 – DET RB Jahmyr Gibbs (GRADE: A)

The duo of Danny and Adam chose to bolster an already impressive running back core by grabbing Jahmyr Gibbs. Unlike the Lions, Thaifighter can’t be ridiculed for taking Gibbs too early, in fact, I’d consider it a steal. Gibbs is an electric factory but he is also unlikely to get a huge workload in the NFL which takes him out of the McCaffrey tier of running back godliness. What he is likely to do is rack up a bunch of RB1 seasons based on pass catching and explosion, and that is pretty exciting at a position where there isn’t a tremendous degree of excitement. Because of the tremendous upside, this pick gets a A, bordering on an A+.
Pick 3.06 – NO RB Kendre Miller (GRADE: B)
Kendre wasn’t one of the prospects that I really googled over. However, his landing spot coupled with the draft capital is strong. He has elite traits such as tackle breaking, legit juice, and youth. He also is primed to see snaps early in the season, giving some instant value. Getting a guy with all those factors, in the third round? It’s hard to grade too heavily against that. The only reason this pick doesn’t get an A? I felt Thaifighter could’ve bolstered another position such as receiver or tight end.
Overall Draft Grade: A-
Justin Fields Forever (1.07, 2.05, 2.07, 3.07)
Going into the draft, I felt that there was a value gap after the seventh pick. I figured Johnston would be here for Luke to take, but with him gone, that left another receiver in Smith Njigba. Luke also had an extra pick this year due to a mid season trade, giving him more youth in an already stacked roster.
Pick 1.07 – SEA WR Jaxon Smith-Njigba (GRADE: A)

I like JSN a lot. He’s the spitting image of Ja’Marr Chase without the truly transcendent stuff that made Chase great. Part of what made Chase great is that he basically put Justin Jefferson in a corner at LSU, all while being a year younger. The problem of Chase’s profile was that he only played two years of college and was more or less invisible as an 18 year old. JSN only had two qualifying years of football and was also more or less invisible as an 18 year old. The one year of data that we had on Ja’Marr was him dominating high quality teammates like Jefferson and Terrace Marshall. The one year of data that we have on JSN is him dominating high caliber teammates like Garrett Wilson and Chris Olave. You see where I’m going with this? The biggest issue is that he will be neutered by his situation in the short and long term due to two star receivers and league worst pass rate. As you can see, though, JSN has been able to be a star amongst stars. Easy grade on an A.
Pick 2.05 – SEA RB Zach Charbonnet (GRADE: B)
Charbonnet has a really exciting profile being a 6’1 220 4.4 40 type guy. He’s a pass catcher so that’s always a plus. He truly gives me Rhamondre Stevenson vibes and he’s a back that profiles well enough to generate excitement almost anywhere…anywhere except for the place he got drafted. It’s an absolute shame as now Charbonnet is stuck behind a guy who he’s more than likely not better than. Kenneth Walker profiles as an explosive bell cow running back who’s weaknesses aren’t prevalent enough to be replaced, so it’s hard to imagine him getting supplanted by someone the likes of Charbonnet. The biggest upside for Charbonnet is the fact he becomes a high priority handcuff in the chance that Walker gets injured for an extended amount of time. Charbonnet is talented so he’s truly worthy of his selection, so I’ll give this pick a solid B.
Pick 2.07 – CAR WR Jonathan Mingo (GRADE: C+)
Prior to the draft, I had absolutely no clue who this guy was. Still really don’t know much about him other than he didn’t produce very much in college and he didn’t really breakout until late in his career. However, he is an another Ole Miss athletic freak, so drafting him this high would assume you’re hoping to get the next DK Metcalf. There is a positive to hang your hat on, though. He gets drafted to a wide open receiver room with a young QB. Mingo’s ADP is absurdly high at this point, so it makes sense he gets drafted in this spot, however, I think there were two better receivers to be had here. C+
Pick 3.07 – CIN RB Chase Brown (GRADE: B)
Brown is an interesting option considered the Joe Mixon off-field issues are hot and cold on a daily basis. there is a chance that he finds his way on the field by way of suspension as well as injury and that is an option that doesn’t seem to be predictably in play for many others. I don’t think he’s the RB of the future so if he can find a way to solidify himself as the RB2 for Cincinnati, a round 3 pick is well worth it. Solid B
Overall Draft Grade: B
Team mikebgopack (1.08, 2.08, 3.08)
After the value pocket of the first seven picks, Mike started the difficult portion of the draft that leaves you either reaching too far or finding diamonds in the rough. Don’t get me wrong, there was plenty of talent left to chose, but as compared to the first seven prospects, you’re looking for contingent value based on draft capital and landing spot.
Pick 1.08 – LV TE Michael Mayer (GRADE: C)

Michael Mayer has been a gleam in fantasy experts’ eyes for years due to his consistent contributions in the pass game. Mayer tied for or led his team in receptions all 3 seasons he played, and he’s an early declare, which usually makes the hit rate for success much higher. The biggest mark against Mayer is his lack of eye popping athleticism that we commonly associate with the freakiest tight ends. There are non-freak tight ends that have emerged as bonafide superstars but they emerge at a much lower rate. Here’s the thing about this pick. If you were going to pick a tight end in the first round of a dynasty draft, this is the year to do so. However, this was not the tight end to do so. Mayer has an indestructible floor but you don’t draft players for their floor in the first round. You draft first round players, specifically tight ends for their upside.
Pick 2.08 – NYG WR Jalin Hyatt (GRADE: C)
Oh man, some guys just aren’t very good bets to make and then when you see a team that makes questionable decision on the daily basis selecting him you simply have to laugh. The Giants making another boneheaded WR selection just two years after taking Kadarius Toney in the first round even though they cleaned house in the interim has to be disheartening for Giants fans everywhere. Hyatt basically comes in as this years’ Jameson Williams by being a complete dud in his first two years and then become a total dude in year 3, but without the first round draft capital. Hyatt’s best intangible is his understanding of leverage and creating separation in off coverage situations on deep overs and post routes, then letting it fly. I feel like I’m picking on Mike with a grade of C, but I felt there were two better prospects in the receiver group to pick.
Pick 3.08 – GB WR Jayden Reed (GRADE: B)
Mike gets the GPA up with the pickup of Jayden Reed late in the third round. I originally valued him towards the middle or top of the third round. With that said, Reed’s profile wasn’t to die for, and I really wouldn’t want anything to do with an offense (GB) that didn’t want to pass the ball with Aaron Rodgers under center. I can’t see it getting any better with Jordan Love slingin it. Jayden very well could succeed, even with this all going against him, but if you can get any kind of production from him this year, getting him in the back end of the draft is well worth it. Solid B based on value.
Overall Draft Grade: B-
Northside Boys (1.09, 2.09, 3.03, 3.09)
With four picks in this years’ draft, Cole had the ability to add some much needed youth in this depth. Prior to the draft, there were evident needs at tight end and quarterback, while the two other skill positions could use some help as well. A trade was made during the draft in which Jared Goff was acquired for a 2024 1st, giving Cole three reasonable starting quarterbacks in case of injury.
Pick 1.09 – MIN WR Jordan Addison (GRADE: A)

Sometimes things work out. Cole was able to get the best player available and it just so happened to be the guy on his favorite team. Even though he rates as my third best receiver, I believe he has the best opportunity to produce right away, even with Jefferson leading the charge. Addison is probably pretty good but when you’re competing with someone the likes of Jefferson, it’s hard to get big time production. He’ll likely be a nice WR2/3. At this point it’ll be a wonder if he’s the Robin to Jefferson’s Batman or if Hockenson is Robin. Is it possible that they both can be Robin? Obviously tons of duos are relevant, but threes a crowd and its hard to know if Hock is actually part of that crowd or not at this point. In the long-term, it’s hard to see a world in which Addison approaches anything that Jefferson can do, thus probably relegating him to a low level henchman. Cole gets the A due to getting the best player available and filling a need all in one pick.
Pick 2.09 – CHI RB Roschon Johnson (GRADE: B-)
As someone that likes running backs in situations that aren’t overly clear who is who in the backfield, Roschon is a good pick, with a chance that he might just run away with the gig. If he doesn’t, then he falls into the contingent upside bucket. We can’t hold his lack of production against him considering the guy in front of him in college (Bijan). Roschon is a decent enough late round pick, however, this would’ve been the perfect time to take a tight end like Sam LaPorta. Not only that, Roschon probably could’ve been grabbed at the 3.03 pick.
Pick 3.03 – LAR QB Stetson Bennett (GRADE: C-)
It’s really hard to like a QB who gets drafted at the age of 25. The dude just led his team to a national championship and then got near zero draft hype. This is likely not a diamond in the rough as every scout in the world got to see a ton of his game film and still turned their nose up. Sure, he’ll back up Matthew Stafford and the curious case of his elbow, but if you’re looking for guys who can start and be productive, there were plenty of other choices. While LaPorta was no longer on the board, Schoonmaker, Washington, and Kraft were all fair tight end choices.
Pick 3.09 – IND WR Josh Downs (GRADE: A)
Finally, someone took this man. While I was never fully in on the Downs hype, he definitely deserved to be picked a full round earlier, at the very least. Downs got nuked in the draft on multiple fronts. First was his free fall to round 3 and then secondly, he got drafted by the team that also drafted Anthony Richardson and already has two good receiving options in Pittman and Jelani Woods. Then you factor in the generational running back and you must question whether or not this team ever intends to pass the football again. With all this said, Downs is a reasonably solid prospect but nothing spectacular. However, he perfectly fits as a steal, going in the third round. If he produces even in the slightest, this will be the pick of the draft. Easy A
Overall Draft Grade: B
Team W.P. (1.10, 2.10, 3.10)
Coming off a championship season, Team W.P. entered the draft with the last pick in the first round. With solid players at the quarterback, receiver, and tight end positions, a running back or two was the biggest need.
Pick 1.10 – MIA RB Devon Achane (GRADE: B)

Devon Achane may be a really good football player in a way that he carves out a role for a long while in the NFL while also not sustaining workloads large enough to ever factor in on a season long basis. His college profile is enough to raise his upside and offset his size. What makes Achane intriguing is the landing spot in Miami. The problem I see arising is do we know if Achane is better than the likes of Wilson or Mostert? At the end of the day, the list of sub 190 pound running backs to become high-volume producers is not long, but he gives me Jahvid Best vibes so he gets a solid B.
Pick 2.10 – TEN RB Tyjae Spears (GRADE: B)
Spears projects like a James Cook clone as a high-efficiency, low volume player in the NFL, though he did handle a larger workload in college. He is a likely satelite back in Tennessee and has some injury concerns. Think Kenny Gainwell with better DC. Speaking of injury concerns, there were reports about his knee being basically held together by duct tape and rubber bands, so there’s always risk associated with a player like that, but if Tennessee felt comfortable enough to draft him in the third round, that should alleviate some of the worry. The pick gets a solid B since Spears typically gets picked in this area of the draft, plus it adds depth to a need.
Pick 3.10 – PIT TE Darnell Washington (GRADE: B)
Mr. Irrelevant in the Wolf Pack Dynasty Rookie Draft. The raw size and talent is far from irrelevant, however. Darnell’s stock has been sinking to the depths of the ocean since his draft day slide and Steelers selection with a nice shot of self-proclaimed “6th o-lineman”. Even with that, he’s truly worth the dart throw and can occupy your taxi squad all year to see how he plays out. The last pick of the draft is basically the first pick of the undrafted rookies so it’s hard to give anything other than a solid B.
Overall Draft Grade: B
Overview
You’ve gotten to see my two cents on the draft…what’s yours? Hopefully this piece was not only entertaining but also useful in discovering some of the lesser known rookies this year.
With the draft in the books, we now play the long wait before the NFL season kicks off. Once we start getting closer to fall, I’ll be completing a full “pre-season” ranking of each team in our league. Thanks for reading!





Leave a Reply